Milestones
Doctoral studentsÌýsubmit several kinds of research papers as milestones to advancing to PhD candidacy status:Ìý
- the Prelim (submitted in the fourth semester of study);
- ³Ù³ó±ðÌýSynthesis (submitted by the end of the sixth semester of study); and
- the Prospectus (submitted in the eighth semester of study).Ìý
Together, the synthesis and prospectus constitute the two-part PhD Comprehensive Exam, after which the student is advanced to candidacy for the doctoral degree.
Milestone 1 – the Prelim
The prelim is the first milestone for PhD students. It is a mentored research paper focused on analysis of some aspect of language relevant to the student’s chosen subfield. The student selects a question, identifies data and appropriate methodology, proposes an analysis of that data and draws conclusions within a cogent linguistic context. The prelim is the student’s opportunity to develop and demonstrate, early in their career, their ability to produce original research.Ìý
A successful prelim will be evaluated by the faculty committee as comparable to a satisfactory contribution to a recognized linguistics conference.
What are the steps involved?
Year 1, first semester in the program – identify a topic & prelim advisor
In consultation with their dissertation advisor, students should explore the research of faculty whose research complements the student’s own interests, attend lab or research group meetings to identify necessary skills and methodologies, and determine an appropriate prelim advisor and committee.
Year 1, second semester in the program – develop theprelim proposalÌý
The 750-1000 word prelim proposal should be prepared with the advisor and must be submitted with their approval to the prelim committee by March 1.
The proposal should include:Ìý
- the question(s) to be investigated as well as the methods and data the student plans to use;
- an explanation of how the prelim will contribute to the student’s research growth (e.g., by exploring relevant data, acquiring new methodologies, situating their questions in analytical frameworks).
- a separate page with references.Ìý
** Due to the short time frame for completion of the prelim, students often consider using existing data sources.
The prelim committee will be composed of the student’s prelim advisor and two additional faculty members from Linguistics, selected by the student and advisor; each committee member will evaluate the proposal according to the following criteria:Ìý
- appropriateness of scope;
- plan for growth; andÌý
- potential for development into a paper that would make a satisfactory contribution to a linguistics conference.Ìý
Students will receive written feedback from the committee by March 15.Ìý
If revisions are required by the committee, a revised proposal is due April 1. If the committee does not approve the revised proposal, the student will have to re-attempt the Prelim in the following cycle.Ìý
After proposal approval through January of the student's second yearÌý(third & early fourth semester) – write the prelim paperÌý& prepare the oral defense.Ìý
Students are encouraged to discuss the paper with committee members before submitting on February 1.
Things to keep in mind:
- A prelim paper is generally more substantial than a typical term paper but should notÌýexceed 10,000 words.Ìý
- The prelim paper for defense is dueÌýto the committee by February 1.
- The oral defense takes place on or near February 15Ìýwith the following format:
- the student presents a 15-minute summary of the paper, after which;
- the student will answer questions from the committee and any other department faculty present for 20-30 minutes.
- The committee discusses their assessment of the prelim exam, both the paper and the oral defense;
- The advisor will provide written feedback from the committee on the paper and oral defense (using the department Prelim milestone form);Ìý
- If any revisions are required by the committee, these must be completed by March 1.Ìý
Unsatisfactory Performance or Postponement
Students who do not achieve a passing Prelim proposal, paper, or oral on their first attempt may, with faculty approval, make a second and final attempt at the complete prelim process in the following cycle.Ìý
In extreme circumstances (e.g., a health or family emergency), the student may submit a petition for delay of submission to the Graduate Chair, and a decision will be made by vote of the faculty. Supporting documentation may be requested.Ìý
Milestone 2 – the SynthesisÌý
The second major milestone in the PhD program is completion of the synthesis paper, which constitutes the first element of the PhD Comprehensive Exam process.
In the synthesis paper, students demonstrate their ability to engage critically and independently with questions of linguistic importance, addressing a focused topic or problem.Ìý
The synthesis paper can be either:
- a critical review of the literature, orÌý
- original research that addresses and considers existingÌýscholarship.
Although the synthesis paper helps the student explore and engage in areas relevant to their eventual dissertation, it is a step along the way; students do not need to have a definite dissertation topic at this point. If the synthesis includes original research, it may constitute a research product ready to be submitted to a conference or possibly for publication. It may also serve as a pilot of dissertation research.
The synthesis paper will be evaluated by the faculty committee as to the quality of its contribution to scholarly conversations in the relevant subarea of linguistics.Ìý
What are the steps involved?
The synthesis paper should be the culmination of an approximately year-long process withÌýsteps undertaken in consultation with the student’s chosen three-member synthesis committee. If the student is very clear about their interests and directions at the beginning of the synthesis process, steps 1 and 2 may be combined in a proposal + bibliography.
1. After completing the prelim, the student and their committee discuss possible directions for the synthesis, moving toward determining a focused research question. The eventual question and/or research might extend from the prelim or from reading / projects related to a course the student has taken (e.g., one of the theory courses). Early stages of the process may involveÌý identifying a general topic area and doing focused reading.
2. The student develops a synthesis proposal and submits it to the committee by early Fall (fifth semester) of the third year in the program.Ìý
The proposal should:
- motivate the question to be addressed;
- describe the approach to be taken (whether a critical synthesis of existing literature or a paper that brings together existing literature and original research involving data);Ìý
- explain how the work will be a meaningful contribution to scholarly conversations in the student’s chosen subarea of linguistics;
- be approximately 1000 words, exclusive of references.
3. Writing the synthesis paperÌý
The final synthesis paper should demonstrate the student’s ability to address a question of linguistic importance and engage with the existing literature within their chosen subarea.
Things to keep in mind:
- The student is welcome to discuss their synthesis project with any members of the committee and to receive feedback from the primary advisor on any draft prior to submission to the full committee.
- A synthesis paper is generally more substantial than a typical term paper but should generally notÌýexceed 10,000 words.
- The synthesis paper is dueÌýto the committee by March 15Ìý(sixth semester) of the student’s third year in the program.Ìý
- the advisor will provide written feedback from the committee on the paper (using the department Synthesis milestone form);Ìý
- revisions, if necessary, should be completed by the end of the semester;Ìý
- all members of the committee must approve the synthesis paper before the synthesis requirement is passed.Ìý
Unsatisfactory PerformanceÌý
Once the synthesis is submitted, the committee evaluates it and may ask for revisions. If the revised synthesis is still not passed by the committee, they may request one last round of revisions, which must be submitted in writing and defended orally. If the committee does not evaluate the second revised synthesis as passed at this point, the student is asked to leave the program.
Milestone 3 – the Dissertation Prospectus
The dissertation prospectus is theÌýthird milestone and constitutes the second and final element of the PhD Comprehensive Exam process.Ìý
Students should defend the prospectus by February 15 in the spring (seventh) semester of their fourth year in the program.Ìý
The five-member dissertation committee will evaluate whether the prospectus demonstrates a plan for a satisfactory dissertation in the student’s chosen subarea of linguistics.Ìý
Things to keep in mind:
- The length and level of detail in the prospectus are variable; the student should discuss these with their dissertation advisor.Ìý
- In the prospectus, the student sets out the state of the art concerning the linguistic questions they have undertaken to address, citing appropriate prior literature, identifying gaps, and explaining what new methods and perspectives are proposed to address those gaps.Ìý
- The prospectus should clearly describe:
- the research plan;
- expected results; andÌý
- the timeline for completing the dissertation project.
- The prospectus will be presented to the committee and defended orally.
The dissertation committee and procedures
The dissertation committee is chosen in consultation with the thesis advisor, who heads the committee.Ìý
In accordance with Graduate School rules, this committee must be composed of:
- a majority of regularly appointedÌýLinguistics department faculty members; and
- at least one CU faculty member from a department outside Linguistics.Ìý
- optionally, a faculty member from another university may be appointed to the dissertation committee but does not count as the outside committee member.
At least two weeks prior to the prospectus defense, the student submits the Comprehensive Exam form with the names of their committee members to the Graduate School.Ìý
After the prospectus defense, the advisor will provide written feedback from the committee (using the department Prospectus milestone form) and students must make all requested revisions to obtain committee approval.Ìý
After successfully defending the dissertation prospectus, the student will apply to the Graduate School to .Ìý
Ìý
- MA in Linguistics
- Computational Linguistics (CLASIC) Master's Degree
- PhD in Linguistics
- Independent Study
- Graduate Certificate Programs
- Graduate Teaching
- Graduate Linguistics Association
- Academic Integrity
- Funding
- Research Resources
- International Graduate Students
- The Graduate Mentorship Program
- Graduate Student FAQs
No prospectus defense can be scheduled until the synthesis paper has received final approval from all members of the synthesis exam committee.
Ìý